https://www.sikich.com

Universities should assess the Title IV composite score impact before refinancing

INSIGHT 6 min read

For colleges and universities participating in federal student aid programs, debt decisions can have consequences beyond financing. Refinancing an existing loan, drawing on a line of credit or issuing new debt may improve liquidity, fund a capital project or provide more favorable repayment terms. But the transaction’s structure can also affect the institution’s U.S. Department of Education financial responsibility composite score.

The Department’s rules do not treat all debt equally when calculating the Primary Reserve Ratio. The connection between debt and the property, plant and equipment (PP&E) it finances can determine whether lenders grant it favorable treatment.

University leaders should model the composite-score impact before refinancing, restructuring or taking on new debt. Once a transaction closes, the options for addressing an unfavorable result may be limited.

How debt proceeds are used can matter more than collateral

For the composite score, how an institution uses debt proceeds can matter more than what secures the debt.

The Department’s financial responsibility rules distinguish between PP&E and long-term debt reported on financial statements submitted before July 1, 2020, generally referred to as “pre-implementation,” and certain PP&E and debt reported on or after that date, generally referred to as “post-implementation.”

This distinction matters because qualified long-term debt can effectively offset certain PP&E deductions when determining expendable net assets for the Primary Reserve Ratio. But debt does not qualify simply because an institution owns PP&E or uses property as collateral. For post-implementation debt, there generally must be a direct connection between qualifying debt and the acquisition of PP&E.

A transaction that meets a university’s financing objectives may not receive favorable Title IV treatment.

For example, a university might borrow against an existing campus building to strengthen liquidity or fund operations. Although the building serves as collateral, the Department’s guidance provides an example in which the borrower secures new debt with existing pre-implementation PP&E but does not use the proceeds to acquire PP&E. As a result, the debt doesn’t qualify as either pre- or post-implementation long-term debt.

Even $1 of additional refinancing proceeds can change debt treatment

Refinancing pre-implementation debt for more than the outstanding balance can change its treatment for composite-score purposes. Under the Department’s guidance, even $1 of excess proceeds can cause the entire refinanced amount to lose its pre-implementation treatment.

To preserve pre-implementation long-term debt when refinancing, the transaction:

  • Can involve a different lender
  • Can have different repayment terms
  • Generally cannot generate proceeds above the existing debt’s outstanding balance

The Department’s guidance does not treat refinancing costs as proceeds.

Consider a university with $10 million of qualifying pre-implementation debt. It might refinance the obligation and borrow an additional $1 million, viewing the added liquidity as an efficient part of the transaction. Because the refinancing produced proceeds above the outstanding balance, however, the refinanced amount would no longer qualify to offset pre-implementation PP&E. The consequences can therefore be disproportionate to the additional borrowing.

Some additional proceeds may qualify as post-implementation debt if used to acquire qualifying PP&E. Timing matters: under the Department’s example, the institution must purchase the newly acquired PP&E before fiscal year-end for the related proceeds to receive that treatment.

How bond proceeds are used can determine debt treatment

For bonds issued after July 1, 2020:

  • All proceeds used for PP&E: The debt may qualify as post-implementation long-term debt, subject to the applicable limitation.
  • Only some proceeds used for PP&E: If a new bond does not limit proceeds to PP&E and the remaining proceeds support other operations or acquisitions, none of the bond indebtedness qualifies under the Department’s identified option.
  • Refinancing with no excess proceeds: The refinancing debt may continue to qualify, subject to applicable PP&E limitations.
  • Refinancing that generates excess proceeds: The analysis becomes more complex and may require separate consideration of the proceeds generated.

The Department provides an alternative for certain bonds when the bond issuer restricts both the original and refinancing bond proceeds to PP&E. That approach requires extensive tracking, including identification of PP&E acquired with the original and refinancing bonds, restricted cash information and an audit trail supporting the financing and PP&E transactions. Organizations must also submit supporting documentation through eZ-Audit while a restricted cash or bond liability balance remains.

Universities should consider the intended use and documentation of bond proceeds when structuring the financing, not simply during the year-end audit.

Credit facilities and construction financing require clear documentation

For credit facilities and construction financing, favorable composite-score treatment can depend on the institution’s ability to connect the debt to the PP&E it finances.

For a credit facility, the Department provides rules for allocating payments between pre-implementation and eligible post-implementation debt. New draws generally represent post-implementation debt, and only the amount the institution can demonstrate was used to purchase PP&E receives the applicable treatment in adjusted equity or expendable net assets.

Construction in progress (CIP) adds another consideration. The regulations remove CIP from expendable net assets, but qualifying short-term loans and lines of credit associated with CIP can affect that calculation. When an institution places construction in service and converts or refinances related short-term financing into long-term debt, the connection between the financing and the property continues to matter.

For significant campus projects, universities should document the connection between financing and related assets throughout the financing process rather than reconstruct it during the audit.

Model the composite score impact before closing

A financing strategy that makes economic sense does not necessarily produce favorable composite-score treatment. Universities should therefore assess a proposed transaction’s Title IV implications as part of the financing decision.

University leaders and their advisors should ask these questions before closing:

  • Is the existing debt classified as pre-implementation or post-implementation for composite-score purposes?
  • Will the refinancing generate proceeds above the existing debt’s outstanding balance?
  • How will the institution use new proceeds?
  • Does the institution expect the debt to qualify as debt associated with PP&E?
  • Can the institution trace specific debt proceeds to the PP&E it plans to acquire?
  • Will those assets be purchased and, when applicable, placed in service within the required reporting period?
  • Does the transaction involve a bond, credit facility or construction project requiring additional tracking?
  • What does the projected composite score look like before and after the transaction?

Universities should model the potential Title IV composite-score impact alongside traditional considerations such as interest rate, liquidity, maturity and debt service. Finance leaders should work through these questions with trusted advisors before transaction finalization, when the structure can be adjusted if necessary. Sikich’s Nonprofit and Title IV teams are available to start the conversation.

Author

Leary Morris, CPA, is a director on the not-for-profit services team at Sikich. Leary has over 10 years of public accounting experience working with social services organizations, membership organizations, private colleges and universities, Title IV schools and more. In her current role, she oversees engagement teams, working directly with staff members and alongside clients.