The Story Behind the Numbers: How Financial Information Showcases Your Impact

Storytelling plays an integral role in our lives, whether it’s teaching a lesson, illustrating a point, or selling a service. Great stories spark creativity and cause people to view the world differently.

Your organization’s financial story is fundamental to achieving your mission and showcasing your accomplishments. It demonstrates impact, increases transparency, and builds trust. It helps you maintain a strong donor base, obtain additional funding, and thrive – even during tough economic times.

Like a good book that’s hard to put down, the most powerful stories feature thought-provoking themes, a range of emotions, a dynamic plot, and complex characters. While nonprofits tell inspiring individual stories of the people they help, they often do a poor job of using their financial success and challenges to tell an engaging story that resonates over time. Accurate numbers add depth and spark action.

Offer More than an Annual Update

Large investment firms provide daily real-time information on the performance of investors’ assets. While donors don’t want or expect to receive similar information on a daily basis from the nonprofits they support, they would like more than an annual update.

Like investors, donors want to receive regular details about the organization managing their money. They hunger for answers to questions like these:

Has the organization grown over the last year? What is its predicted growth in the coming year?

How does the organization measure programmatic and financial success?

What percentage of funds covers administrative expenses?

What are the organization’s sources of revenue? Is the organization primarily state or federally funded or does it receive funding from a variety of sources?

How does the organization monitor compensation levels for its staff?

How many people sit on the organization’s board? Where do they work?

Does the board have a financial expert?

When you treat donors the way fund managers treat their top investors, you’ll reap rewards. Your stakeholders will feel valued, embrace your organization’s story, and commit to investing in your success.

Forget the Balance Sheet

What’s the best way to share your story with stakeholders? Start by surveying donors. Ask them how often they want to receive information and through which medium (e-mail, mail, etc.).

In your communication with donors, prioritize key financial highlights. Don’t overwhelm donors with entire balance sheets, income statements, and hundreds of numbers. Instead, help them understand how they can help write the next chapter in your organization’s story. Share only relevant and abbreviated information that provides insight into the organization’s financial status, including:

  • Total revenue
  • Total expenses
  • Change in net assets

Relate all financial results to your mission. Make the information clear, concise, and accurate. Never assume that everyone interprets data points in the same way. You need to show donors why the information matters and explain its implications in the short and long term. Graphs and charts can help present the data in a compelling way since pictures often tell a clearer story than words.

Despite the digital age, far too many nonprofits waste thousands of dollars sending donors printed financial materials – including balance sheets and income statements – via mail. Customized e-mail communication saves valuable resources.

Companies present both negative and positive information to their stakeholders. They often invest millions of dollars in “reputation management” for numerous reasons – including protection during crises. You can do the same. You can build trust and strengthen your reputation with financial transparency. A reputation for strong financial health over time can lead to increased support from individual donors when state and federal funding falls short during a budget crisis or when unexpected costs arise.

Connect Mind with Heart

Individuals everywhere yearn for stories that evoke emotion. Crafting a financial narrative alongside inspiring examples of human impact taps into stakeholders’ emotions and motivates them to invest their intellectual and financial resources in your mission. Nonprofits serve as agents for positive societal change. By leveraging the power of an authentic and holistic story, effective communication with stakeholders makes this change a reality for people around the world – every day.

This publication contains general information only and Sikich is not, by means of this publication, rendering accounting, business, financial, investment, legal, tax, or any other professional advice or services. This publication is not a substitute for such professional advice or services, nor should you use it as a basis for any decision, action or omission that may affect you or your business. Before making any decision, taking any action or omitting an action that may affect you or your business, you should consult a qualified professional advisor. In addition, this publication may contain certain content generated by an artificial intelligence (AI) language model. You acknowledge that Sikich shall not be responsible for any loss sustained by you or any person who relies on this publication.

About the Author